We here at Chakra are committed to telling you the whole truth. We don't hide anything, although we have our own perspective, which is independent and not dictated to us by the GBC. At CHAKRA, although we are friends with the GBC, we only present our own views. We speak of our own free will.

Return to the Book-Editing Page

Prabhupada's Books Must Change

By Hari Sauri Dasa

I am not sure who the devotee is that Ananda prabhu is referring to in his text, but I appreciate his stout defence of Jayadvaita Maharaja, who was indeed given a mandate by Srila Prabhupada to edit his books to increasingly better standards. He trusted that he was competent to do this without changing the message. Having worked with Maharaja on the BTG for a year and also having gone into detail with him in the early 80s on the update of the Bhagavad-gita, I can certify that Jayadvaita Maharaja is meticulous in preserving Srila Prabhupada's message while presenting it in the best way possible.
Back Home

In case anyone has anyone doubts that this on-going work of improvement should be done, here's what Srila Prabhupada himself said in the last few weeks he was with us. This is part of a conversation that took place when Harikesa Maharaja arrived from Germany with some newly printed books for distribution in Germany and Europe: a clear confirmation that Prabhupada wanted his books to be corrected:

Rm. Conv. October 10 1977: [After seeing new books printed by Harikesa Swami]

Prabhupada: "So here is a intelligent boy. Why he should rot here, typewriting? (break) Whatever deficiency are there, that is excused by Guru Maharaja. Go on printing, go on printing. Deficiency will be corrected, next, next, next. I printed Bhagavata in that way, many defects. "All right. Whatever is printed, that’s all." But these are first class. There is no defect. German printing is very pure. They have got the first-class machine. So we have got so many centers. Wherever cheaper and better printing can be gotten, we may take from there. That’s all right. Thank you."

This is clear and it is probably the last direct instruction from Srila Prabhupada regarding the continual improvement of his books: "Whatever deficiency are there, that is excused by Guru Maharaja. Go on printing, go on printing. Deficiency will be corrected, next, next, next. I printed Bhagavata in that way, many defects. "All right. Whatever is printed, that’s all."

CHAKRA 23-Apr-98

Return to the Book-Editing Page

© Copyright November, 2003 by oldchakra.com. All rights reserved.

For information about this website or to report an error, write to webmaster@oldchakra.com